Section II ST segment depression ischemia and non–Q wave infarct patterns
Myocardial infarction (MI) may be associated with abnormal Q waves and the typical progression of ST-T changes described in Chapter 8 . In other cases, however, myocardial ischemia (with or without actual infarction) may be limited primarily to the subendocardium (inner layer) of the ventricle.
SUBENDOCARDIAL ISCHEMIA
How can subendocardial ischemia occur without transmural ischemia or infarction? The subendocardium is particularly vulnerable to ischemia because it is most distant from the coronary blood supply and closest to the high pressure of the ventricular cavity. This inner layer of the ventricle can become ischemic while the outer layer (epicardium) remains normally perfused with blood.
The most common ECG change with subendocardial ischemia is ST segment depression ( Fig. 9-1 ). The ST depression may be limited to the anterior leads (I, aVL, and V1 to V6) or to the inferior leads (II, III, and aVF), or it may be seen more diffusely in both groups of leads. As shown in Figure 9-1 , the ST depression with subendocardial ischemia has a characteristic squared-off shape. (ST segment elevation is usually seen in lead aVR.)
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
FIGURE 9-1 Subendocardial ischemia may produce ST depressions. |
|
Recall from the previous chapter that acute transmural ischemia produces ST segment elevation, a current of injury pattern. This results from epicardial injury. With pure subendocardial ischemia, just the opposite occurs; that is, the ECG shows ST segment depression (except in lead aVR, which typically shows ST elevation).
In summary, myocardial ischemia involving primarily the subendocardium usually produces ST segment depression, whereas acute ischemia involving the epicardium usually produces ST elevation. (This difference in the direction of the injury current vector is depicted in Figure 9-2 .)
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
FIGURE 9-2 A With acute subendocardial ischemia the electrical forces (arrows) responsible for the ST segment are deviated toward the inner layer of the heart, causing ST depressions in lead V5, which faces the outer surface of the heart. B, With acute transmural (epicardial) ischemia, electrical forces (arrows) responsible for the ST segment are deviated toward the outer layer of the heart, causing ST elevations in the overlying lead. |
|
ECG CHANGES WITH ANGINA PECTORIS
The term angina pectoris refers to transient attacks of chest discomfort caused by myocardial ischemia. Angina is a symptom of coronary artery disease. The classic attack of angina is experienced as a dull, burning, or boring substernal pressure or heaviness. It is typically precipitated by exertion, stress, exposure to cold, and other factors, and it is relieved by rest and nitroglycerin.
Many (but not all) patients with classic angina have an ECG pattern of subendocardial ischemia, with ST depressions seen during an attack. When the pain disappears, the ST segments generally return to the baseline. ( Figure 9-3 shows ST depressions during a spontaneous episode of angina.)
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
FIGURE 9-3 A Marked ST depressions are seen in the ECG from a patient who complained of chest pain while being examined. B, Five minutes later, after the patient was given sublingual nitroglycerin, the ST segments have reverted to normal, with relief of angina. |
|
The ECGs of some patients with angina do not show ST depressions during chest pain. Consequently, the presence of a normal ECG does not rule out underlying coronary artery disease. The appearance of transient ST depressions in the ECG of a patient with chest pain is, however, a very strong indicator of myocardial ischemia.
EXERCISE TESTING AND CORONARY ARTERY DISEASE
Many patients with coronary artery disease have a normal ECG while at rest. During exercise, however, ischemic changes may appear because of the extra oxygen requirements imposed on the heart by exertion. To assist in diagnosing coronary artery disease, the cardiologist can record the ECG while the patient is being exercised under controlled conditions. Stress electrocardiography is usually performed while the patient walks on a treadmill or pedals a bicycle. The test is stopped when the patient develops angina, fatigue, or diagnostic ST changes or when the heart rate reaches 85% to 90% of a maximum predetermined rate predicted from the patient's age. This approach is known as submaximal testing.
Figure 9-4 A is the normal resting ECG of a patient, whereas Figure 9-4 B shows the marked ST depressions recorded while the patient was exercising. The appearance of ST segment depressions constitutes a positive (abnormal) result. Most cardiologists accept horizontal or downward ST depressions of at least 1 mm or more, lasting at least 0.08 second (2 small boxes) as a positive (abnormal) test result (see Fig. 9-4 B). ST depressions of less than 1 mm (or depressions of only the J point) with a rapid upward sloping of the ST segment are considered a negative (normal) test response ( Fig. 9-5).
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
FIGURE 9-4 A Baseline rhythm strip from the positive exercise test of a patient with coronary artery disease. B, Notice the marked ST depressions with increased heart rate. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
FIGURE 9-5 Lead V5 shows physiologic ST segment depression that may occur with exercise. Notice the J junction depression (arrow) with sharply upsloping ST segments. (From Goldberger AL: Myocardial Infarction: Electrocardiographic Differential Diagnosis, 4th ed, St. Louis, Mosby, 1991.) |
|
The finding of prominent ischemic ST changes, with or without symptoms, occurring at a low level of activity is particularly ominous.
Exercise electrocardiography is often helpful in diagnosing coronary artery disease. Like all tests, however, it may give both false-positive and false-negative results. For example, up to 10% of normal men and an even higher percentage of normal women may have false-positive exercise tests.
False-positive tests (defined as ST depressions without obstructive coronary disease) can also be seen in patients who are taking digitalis and in patients who have hypokalemia, left ventricular hypertrophy (LVH), ventricular conduction disturbances, or Wolff-Parkinson-White patterns (see Chapter 12 ).
False-negative tests can occur despite the presence of significant underlying coronary artery disease. A normal “negative” exercise test does not exclude coronary artery disease. The diagnostic accuracy of exercise tests may be increased in selected patients by simultaneous imaging studies, using echocardiography or nuclear medicine scans.
In summary, subendocardial ischemia, such as occurs with typical angina pectoris (and as may be elicited with stress testing), often produces ST segment depressions in multiple leads.
“SILENT” MYOCARDIAL ISCHEMIA
A patient with coronary artery disease may have episodes of myocardial ischemia without angina, hence the term silent ischemia. Silent ischemia is sometimes detected during exercise testing. Ambulatory ECG (Holter) monitoring is another useful way to assess silent myocardial ischemia (see Chapter 3 ). 24-hour ECG monitoring of patients with coronary artery disease reveals a surprisingly high frequency of ST depressions not associated with angina. This important topic is discussed again later in this chapter.
SUBENDOCARDIAL INFARCTION
If ischemia of the subendocardial region is severe enough, actual infarction may occur. In such cases, the ECG may show more persistent ST depressions instead of the transient depressions seen with reversible subendocardial ischemia.
Figure 9-6 shows an example of a non–Q wave infarction with persistent ST depressions. Is it possible for Q waves to appear with pure subendocardial infarction? The answer is that if only the inner half of the myocardium is infarcted, abnormal Q waves usually do not appear. Subendocardial infarction generally affects ventricular repolarization (ST-T complex) and not depolarization (QRS complex). As discussed at the end of this chapter, however, important exceptions may occur, and so-called nontransmural infarctions, particularly larger ones, may be associated with Q waves.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
FIGURE 9-6 Non–Q wave infarction in a patient who complained of severe chest pain. Subsequently, the patient's cardiac enzyme levels were elevated. Notice the marked, diffuse ST depressions in leads I, II, III, aVL, aVF, and V2 to V6, in conjunction with the ST elevation in lead aVR. These findings are consistent with severe subendocardial ischemia. Other abnormalities include a prolonged PR interval (0.28 sec) and left atrial abnormality. |
|
Another ECG pattern sometimes seen in non–Q wave infarction is T wave inversions with or without ST segment depressions. Figure 9-7 shows an infarction pattern with deep T wave inversions. (T wave inversions may also be seen in some cases of noninfarctional ischemia.)
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
FIGURE 9-7 Non–Q wave infarction in a patient who complained of chest pain and also had elevated cardiac enzyme levels. Notice the deep T wave inversions in leads I, aVL, and V2 to V6. (Prominent Q waves in III and aVF represent an old inferior wall infarction.) Patients with acute myocardial infarction may have ST segment depressions or T wave inversions without Q waves. |
|
In summary, non–Q wave infarction can be associated with persistent ST depressions and/or T wave inversions.
VARIETY OF ECG CHANGES SEEN WITH MYOCARDIAL ISCHEMIA
Myocardial ischemia clearly can produce a wide variety of ECG changes. For example, infarction may cause abnormal Q waves in association with ST segment elevations followed by T wave inversions. Ventricular aneurysm may be associated with persistent ST segment elevations. Subendocardial ischemia (e.g., during an anginal attack or a stress test) may produce transient ST depressions. In other cases, infarction may be associated with ST depressions or T wave inversions without Q waves.
ECG CHANGES ASSOCIATED WITH NONINFARCTION ISCHEMIA
Myocardial ischemia does not always cause diagnostic ST-T changes. Several other patterns may be seen. In some patients, the ECG may remain entirely normal during episodes of ischemia. In others, the ST-T complex may display only subtle changes. For example, you may see just slight T wave flattening or minimal T wave inversions. These are nonspecific ST-T changes (see Chapter 10 ).
Nonspecific ST-T changes may be abnormal, but they are not definite indicators of ischemia. They may be a sign of ischemic heart disease, but they may also be caused by many other conditions, including drug effects, hyperventilation, and electrolyte abnormalities. Therefore you should not make a definite diagnosis of myocardial ischemia solely on the basis of nonspecific ST-T changes.
Prinzmetal's angina is another form of noninfarction ischemia. Recall that the ECG with classic or typical angina often shows the pattern of subendocardial ischemia with ST segment depressions. An atypical form of angina (first reported by Dr. M. Prinzmetal) is seen in a small but important group of patients. Their angina is atypical because, during episodes of chest pain, they have ST segment elevations, a pattern described previously with acute transmural MI. In Prinzmetal's angina, the ST segment elevations are transient. After the episode of chest pain, the ST segments usually return to the baseline, without the characteristic evolving pattern of Q waves and T wave inversions that occur with acute transmural MI. Thus Prinzmetal's angina is atypical because the ECG shows ST elevations rather than the ST depressions seen with typical angina.
Patients with Prinzmetal's angina are also atypical because their chest pain often occurs at rest or at night. (In contrast, patients with classic angina pectoris usually have chest pain with exertion or emotional stress.) Prinzmetal's angina pattern is significant because it is a marker of coronary artery spasm that causes transient transmural ischemia. These episodes of spasm may occur in patients with otherwise normal coronary arteries. In most cases, spasm is associated with high-grade coronary obstruction ( Fig. 9-8 ). Increasing evidence implicates cocaine as another cause of coronary spasm, sometimes leading to MI.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
FIGURE 9-8 Prinzmetal's (variant) angina with transient ST elevations in a 30-year-old man with a history of angina with exertion and at rest. A, The baseline resting ECG shows nonspecific inferior lead ST-T changes. B With chest pain, marked ST segment elevations occur in leads II, III, and aVF, and reciprocal ST depressions are seen in leads I and aVL. The rightward axis shift and slight widening of the QRS complex are consistent with left posterior fascicular block. C The ST segments return to baseline after the patient is given nitroglycerin. Cardiac catheterization showed severe right coronary obstruction with intermittent spasm producing total occlusion and transient ST elevations. (From Goldberger AL: Myocardial Infarction: Electrocardiographic Differential Diagnosis, 4th ed, St. Louis, Mosby, 1991.) |
|
At this point, the diverse ECG changes seen with ischemic heart disease can be summarized. These changes may include Q waves, ST segment elevations or depressions, tall positive T waves or deep T wave inversions, nonspecific ST-T changes, and even a normal ECG ( Fig. 9-9 ).
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
FIGURE 9-9 Myocardial ischemia produces diverse ECG changes. T wave inversions may also occur with noninfarctional ischemia. Sometimes the ECG may be normal or show only nonspecific ST-T changes. ST elevation infarction is not always followed by Q waves. |
|
ST SEGMENT ELEVATIONS: DIFFERENTIAL DIAGNOSIS
ST segment elevations (current of injury pattern) are the earliest sign of acute transmural ischemia with infarction. Transient elevations are also seen with Prinzmetal's angina. ST segment elevations persisting for several weeks after an acute MI may be a sign of a ventricular aneurysm.
In Figure 9-10 (the ECG of a normal young adult), notice the marked elevation of the ST segments. This is a benign variant known as the early repolarization pattern. With early repolarization, the ST segments in the chest leads may rise to 2 to 3 mm above the baseline. Although most common in young people, these ST elevations can also occur in older persons, simulating the pattern seen with acute pericarditis or MI. The elevations are stable, however, and do not undergo the evolutionary sequence seen with acute pericarditis ( Chapter 11 ). Furthermore, they are not associated with reciprocal ST depressions (except in lead aVR), contrary to what is often observed with acute MI.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
FIGURE 9-10 ST segment elevation, usually most marked in the chest leads, is sometimes seen as a normal variant. This so-called early repolarization pattern may be confused with the ST segment elevations of acute myocardial infarction or pericarditis. |
|
ST segment elevations, resembling myocardial infarction or pericarditis, may also be seen with acute myocarditis ( Chapter 11 ). Chronic ST elevations are often seen in leads V1 and V2 in association with the patterns of LVH or left bundle branch block (LBBB) ( Chapter 7 ). Other causes of ST elevations include systemic hypothermia (J waves or Osborn waves, Chapter 10 ) and the Brugada pattern (Chapter 19 ). A comprehensive “instant review” summary of the differential diagnosis of ST segment elevations is given in Chapter 24 .
ST SEGMENT DEPRESSIONS: DIFFERENTIAL DIAGNOSIS
Subendocardial ischemia is usually characterized by ST segment depression. Not all ST depressions are indicative of subendocardial ischemia, however. For example, the ST-T changes associated with LVH (formerly referred to as the “strain” pattern) were discussed in Chapter 6 . As shown in Figure 6-12 , the ST segment may be slightly depressed with LVH. Acute transmural ischemia is another cause of ST segment depressions.
Remember that acute anterior wall ischemia may be associated with reciprocal ST depressions in one or more of leads II, III, and aVF. Conversely, acute inferior wall ischemia may be associated with reciprocal ST depressions in one or more of the anterior leads (I, aVl, V1 to V3). Therefore whenever you see ST depressions, you need to look at all the leads and evaluate these changes in context.
The ST segment may also be depressed by two important and common factors: digitalis effect and hypokalemia (see Chapter 10 ). Digitalis may produce scooping of the ST-T complex with slight ST depression (see Fig. 10-1 ). The ST segment may also be somewhat depressed in the ECGs of patients with a low serum potassium level (see Fig. 10-8 ). Prominent U waves may also appear. In some cases, it may be difficult to sort out which factors are responsible for the ST depressions you are seeing. For example, a patient with LVH may be taking digitalis and may also be having acute subendocardial ischemia.
A comprehensive “instant review” summary of the differential diagnosis of ST segment depressions is given in Chapter 24 .
DEEP T WAVE INVERSIONS: DIFFERENTIAL DIAGNOSIS
Deep T wave inversions, as described previously, usually occur during the evolving phase of a Q wave MI (see Fig. 8-4 B) and also sometimes with a non–Q wave MI (see Fig. 9-7 ). These deep inversions are the result of a delay in regional repolarization produced by the ischemic injury.
Just as not all ST segment elevations reflect ischemia, however, not all deep T wave inversions are abnormal. For example, T wave inversions may be seen normally in leads with a negative QRS complex(e.g., in lead aVR). In adults, the T wave may be normally negative in lead V1 and sometimes also in lead V2. Furthermore, as mentioned in Chapter 4 , some adults have a persistent juvenile T wave inversion pattern, with negative T waves in the right and middle chest leads (typically V1 to V3).
In addition, not all abnormal T wave inversions are caused by MI. T wave inversions in the right chest leads may be caused by right ventricular overload and in the left chest leads by left ventricular overload ( Chapter 6 ). Diffusely inverted T waves are seen during the evolving phase of pericarditis.
Very deep, widely splayed T wave inversions (with a long QT interval and sometimes prominent U waves) have been described in some patients with cerebrovascular accident (CVA), particularly subarachnoid hemorrhage (CVA T wave pattern) ( Fig. 9-11 ). The cause of these marked repolarization changes in some types of cerebrovascular injury is not certain, but they probably reflect changes in the autonomic nervous system.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
FIGURE 9-11 The ECG of a patient with acute subarachnoid hemorrhage shows giant T wave inversions. Heart rate was about 40/min. Subarachnoid hemorrhage may cause deeply inverted T waves, usually with markedly prolonged QT intervals, simulating the pattern seen in myocardial infarction. Bradycardia is often present. (From Goldberger AL: Myocardial Infarction: Electrocardiographic Differential Diagnosis, 4th ed, St. Louis, Mosby, 1991.) |
|
As described in Chapter 7 , secondary T wave inversions (resulting from abnormal depolarization) are seen in the right chest leads with right bundle branch block (RBBB) and in the left chest leads with LBBB. Deep T wave inversions also occur after electronic ventricular pacing (“postpacemaker” T wave pattern).
This list of noninfarctional factors that cause T wave inversions is by no means complete; however, it should convey the point that T wave inversions are not always indicative of myocardial ischemia. In some cases, deep diffuse (global) T wave inversions may occur without any identifiable cause.
A comprehensive “instant review” summary of the differential diagnosis of T wave inversions is given in Chapter 24 .
COMPLICATIONS OF MYOCARDIAL INFARCTION
The major complications of MI can be either mechanical/structural or electrical. The mechanical complications include heart failure, cardiogenic shock, left ventricular aneurysm, rupture of the heart, pericarditis, papillary muscle dysfunction, infarct extension and expansion, and embolism. The electrical complications include the arrhythmias and conduction disturbances that occur as a consequence of ischemia or infarction. MI can cause virtually any arrhythmia, including sustained ventricular tachycardia or ventricular fibrillation leading to cardiac arrest. (The general subject of arrhythmias is discussed in Part II.) The conduction disturbances include atrioventricular block (heart block) and intraventricular block (bundle branch block) (see Chapters 7 and 17 ).
ECG AFTER CORONARY REPERFUSION
ECG recognition of acute MIs is important because such patients are generally candidates for emergency coronary reperfusion with catheterization/angioplasty-related procedures or with intravenous thrombolytic therapy. As noted in Chapter 8 , thrombolytic therapy has only proved helpful in cases of ST elevation MI (STEMI). Current evidence suggests that acute angioplasty, when feasible, is even more efficacious in this setting and it may also be useful in selected patients with non–ST elevation MI.
Acute reperfusion therapies may alter the usual ECG evolution. Immediate successful reperfusion very early after an acute MI may be marked by the return of elevated ST segments toward the baseline, without new Q waves. Deep T wave inversions may evolve in leads that showed ST elevations. Q waves often appear even after successful reperfusion, however, although the intervention may lessen the amount of myocardium that is affected by the infarction. As a rule, the longer the time after the onset of ischemia or infarction, the less effect reperfusion has on acute or evolving ECG changes.
THE ECG IN MYOCARDIAL INFARCTION: A CLINICAL PERSPECTIVE
One final note of caution should be emphasized: The ECG is a reasonably sensitive but hardly perfect indicator of acute MI. Most patients with an acute MI or severe ischemia show the ECG changes described in Chapter 8 . The ECG may be relatively nondiagnostic or even normal, however, particularly during the early minutes or hours after an infarction. Furthermore, an LBBB or pacemaker pattern may completely mask the changes of an acute infarct.
The ECG therefore must always be considered in clinical perspective, and the diagnosis of myocardial ischemia or infarction should not be dismissed simply because the ECG does not show the classic changes.
In addition, as noted earlier, the traditional distinction between transmural and subendocardial (nontransmural) MIs on the basis of the ECG findings is an oversimplification and often invalid. In some patients, extensive infarction may occur without Q waves; in others, nontransmural injury may occur with Q waves. Furthermore, substantial evidence indicates that subendocardial infarction may have as ominous a long-term prognosis as transmural infarction. For these reasons, cardiologists have appropriately abandoned the terms transmural and subendocardial when describing a clinically diagnosed infarction and instead more appropriately use the more descriptive terms: Q wave and non–Q wave MI.
REVIEW
Subendocardial ischemia generally produces ST segment depressions, which may appear only in the anterior leads (I, aVL, and V1 to V6), only in the inferior leads (II, III, and aVF), or diffusely in both groups of leads. (Lead aVR usually shows ST segment elevations.)
These ischemic ST segment depressions may be seen during attacks of typical angina pectoris. Similar ST segment depressions may develop during exercise (with or without chest pain) in patients with ischemic heart disease. The presence of ischemic heart disease may be determined by recording the ECG during exercise (stress electrocardiography). ST segment depression of 1 mm or more, lasting 0.08 second or more, is generally considered a positive (abnormal) response. False-negative (normal) results can occur, however, in patients with ischemic heart disease and false-positive results can occur in normal people.
Ischemic ST segment changes may also be detected during ambulatory ECG (Holter) monitoring. Analysis of these records has shown that many episodes of myocardial ischemia are not associated with angina pectoris (silent ischemia).
With non–Q wave infarction, the ECG may show persistent ST segment depressions or T wave inversions. Abnormal Q waves do not usually occur with subendocardial infarction limited to the inner half of the ventricular wall.
With Prinzmetal's angina, transient ST segment elevations suggestive of epicardial or transmural ischemia occur during attacks of angina. Patients with Prinzmetal's angina often have atypical chest pain that occurs at rest or at night. In contrast, patients with classic angina, typically have exertional pain that is associated with ST segment depressions. Prinzmetal's (variant) angina pattern is generally a marker of coronary artery spasm with or without underlying coronary obstruction.
The ST segment elevations of acute transmural MI can be simulated by the ST elevations of Prinzmetal's angina, the normal variant ST elevations seen in some healthy people (early repolarization pattern), the ST elevations of acute pericarditis (see Chapter 11 ), along with a number of other conditions summarized in Chapter 24 .
The abnormal ST depressions of subendocardial ischemia may be simulated by the repolarization abnormalities of left ventricular hypertrophy, digitalis effect (see Chapter 10 ), or hypokalemia (seeChapter 10 ), as well as other conditions summarized in Chapter 24 .
T wave inversions can be a sign of ischemia or infarction, but they may also occur in a variety of other settings (see Chapter 24 ), such as in normal variants, with ventricular hypertrophy or subarachnoid hemorrhage, after ventricular pacing, or as part of secondary ST-T changes from bundle branch block.
QUESTIONS— CHAPTERS 8 AND 9
|
1. |
Answer these questions about the ECG shown below:
|
|||||||||||||||||
|
2. |
Answer these questions about the ECG shown below:
|
|||||||||||||||||
|
3. |
With acute transmural anterior wall ischemia, the ST segments in leads II, III, and aVF are likely to be ______. |
|||||||||||||||||
|
4. |
Persistent ST elevations several weeks or more after an infarction may be a sign of ______. |
|||||||||||||||||
|
5. |
A patient with severe chest pain has prominent ST segment depressions in leads I, II, aVL, aVF, and V2 to V5, with abnormal elevations of cardiac enzymes. Which of the listed conditions is the most likely diagnosis?
|
|||||||||||||||||
|
6. |
What ECG abnormality is shown below, and what symptoms might this patient be having?
|
|||||||||||||||||
|
7. |
What conduction disturbance is present in the ECG below? What other major abnormality is present?
|
|||||||||||||||||
|
8. |
True or false: Thrombolytic therapy is equally effective for acute ST segment elevation MI and ST segment depression MI. |
