Joseph S. Sanfilippo
Lisa M. Roberts
In one sense, the historical perspective of endoscopic surgery begins in 1847, with Sir James Y. Simpson of Edinburgh, Scotland, introducing chloroform narcosis. This advance was followed by the first endoscopic evaluation of the abdominal cavity, using a dog model in 1901, by Kelling. Ten years later, Jacobaeus reported the first laparoscopic procedure in the human. Cold illumination fiberoptics followed, by Semm in 1963, and then the surgical area rapidly evolved. The first laparoscopic appendectomy was performed in 1980 and the first cholecystectomy in 1985.
This relatively new aspect of endoscopic surgery has far-reaching and ever increasing innovative aspects. Hysteroscopy has altered the approach to the myomatous uterus. Laparoscopy has blossomed to include radical hysterectomies and node sampling. This chapter provides the technical advances in a segment of gynecologic surgery that appears to be in a continuous state of evolution and ever more far-reaching new instrumentation.
LAPAROSCOPY
Patient Positioning
Proper patient positioning is paramount. The surgeon should position the patient so as to prevent any excessive pressure on the lower extremities. Nerve injuries can result from improper placement of the lower extremities in stirrups. Lithotomy position with access to steep Trendelenburg is appropriate. The physician should discuss with anesthesia personnel decisions regarding whether the arms should be extended or “tucked” along the sides of the patient. The latter requires particular attention to prevent any trauma to the hands and fingers when the table is maneuvered.
With the patient in the low lithotomy position and the legs supported in stirrups, the buttocks should protrude slightly from the lower edge of the table. The lateral aspect of the knee should be protected with padding in the stirrup to prevent peroneal nerve injury. The knees should be kept in slight flexion to minimize stretching of the sciatic nerves and to provide increased stability in the Trendelenburg position. With respect to positioning of the arms, care should be taken not to stretch or traumatize the brachial plexus.
It has been advocated that an angle of 145 degrees between the abdomen and the lower extremity (thigh) is ideal, providing the surgeon with adequate space for instrumentation. The typical patient positioning for endoscopic surgery is noted in Figure 46.1.
|
|
|
FIG. 46.1. Patient positioning for laparoscopic surgery. |
Equipment
An array of instruments designed to facilitate operative laparoscopic procedures continues to evolve. This section describes a number of instruments.
Viewing System
The video equipment should include a three-chip camera, a processor, a 300-watt xenon light source with fiberoptic cable, a high-resolution monitor, and a video recorder. The three-chip camera provides a sharper, brighter image with higher resolution than the older single-chip cameras (Fig. 46.2). Three-chip cameras can deliver over 600 lines of resolution; therefore, the video monitor's horizontal resolution should be greater to maximize image quality. Fiber light cables should be inspected for broken fibers, because damaged fibers will result in suboptimal light delivery.
|
|
|
FIG. 46.2. Autoclavable Goldtip videolaparoscope with camera processor and xenon light source (Olympus, Melville, NY). |
Table
An operating room table that allows 30 degrees of flexion (Trendelenburg position) is ideal for visualization of the deep pelvis. Shoulder braces (Stierlen-Maquet Shoulder Braces, Siemens Medical Systems, Englewood, CO) placed at the acromioclavicular joints and the arms placed at the patient's sides will minimize nerve injuries.
Insufflator
For most procedures, the pneumoperitoneum may be maintained with an insufflator that flows at a rate of 2 to 7 L/min. High-flow insufflators that achieve up to 30 L/min are available and will maintain the pneumoperitoneum during procedures that allow escape of large amounts of CO2, such as during tissue morcellation.
Carbon Dioxide Warmer
There is evidence that warmed CO2 is less irritating to the peritoneal surface and, therefore, may cause less adhesion formation. CO2 warmers are commercially available.
Laparoscopes
Laparoscopes are telescopes that vary in size from 2 to 10 mm. Zero-degree, 30-degree, 45-degree, and 70-degree viewing angles are available. Diagnostic laparoscopes do not contain an operating channel. Operative laparoscopes contain a channel through which instruments or laser may be passed, but they have a smaller number of optic fibers (Fig. 46.3 and Fig. 46.4).
|
|
|
FIG. 46.3. Five-millimeter laparoscopes (Karl Storz Endoscopy-America, Culver City, CA). |
|
|
|
FIG. 46.4. Ten-millimeter laparoscope (Karl Storz Endoscopy-America, Culver City, CA). |
Trocars
Trocars come in a variety of sizes, materials, and designs. Sizes range from 3 to 15 mm. Reusable metal trocars have the advantage of cost efficiency, but they may actually be more dangerous if the tips are not kept sharp (Fig. 46.5, Fig. 46.6 and Fig. 46.7). Disposable trocars are more expensive but are always sharp, which may decrease the risk of injury during insertion (Fig. 46.8). Some trocars are designed to stretch the fascia so that fascial closure is not necessary. Others have been designed to allow visualization of tissue layer separation with the laparoscope during insertion. Advocates assert that this type of trocar decreases bowel and vascular injuries. There are no objective data supportive of a reduction in risk for any trocar. The trocar chosen should be based on the surgeon's preference. Hasson-type trocars have a blunt end for placement in open laparoscopy (Fig. 46.9 and Fig. 46.10).
|
|
|
FIG. 46.5. Five- and ten-millimeter trocars (Karl Storz Endoscopy-America, Culver City, CA). |
|
|
|
FIG. 46.6. Autoclavable 5-mm slim trocar with duckbill (Olympus, Melville NY). |
|
|
|
FIG. 46.7. Five- and ten-millimeter reusable trocars. |
|
|
|
FIG. 46.8. Ten-millimeter disposable trocar (Olympus, Melville, NY). |
|
|
|
FIG. 46.9. Ten-millimeter blunt trocar for open laparoscopy (Marlow Surgical Technologies, Inc., Willoughby, OH). |
|
|
|
FIG. 46.10. Ten-millimeter blunt trocar for open laparoscopy (Apple Medical, Bolton, MA). |
Operating Instruments
A standard laparoscopy set should include the following:
· Trocars
· Bipolar forceps (Fig. 46.11 and Fig. 46.12)
|
|
|
FIG. 46.11. Five-millimeter bipolar forceps (Olympus, Melville, NY). |
|
|
|
FIG. 46.12. Five-millimeter bipolar forceps (Olympus, Melville, NY). |
· Atraumatic grasping forceps (Fig. 46.13, Fig. 46.14 and Fig. 46.15)
|
|
|
FIG. 46.13. Atraumatic tissue grasper (Applied Medical, Rancho Santa Margarita, CA). |
|
|
|
FIG. 46.14. Atraumatic tissue grasper. |
|
|
|
FIG. 46.15. Atraumatic tissue grasper. |
· Biopsy forceps (Fig. 46.16)
|
|
|
FIG. 46.16. Biopsy forceps. |
· Blunt probe
· Blunt sawtooth scissors (Fig. 46.17)
|
|
|
FIG. 46.17. Blunt sawtooth scissors (Richard Wolf Medical Instruments, Vernon Hills, IL). |
· Pointed Metzenbaum scissors (Fig. 46.18)
|
|
|
FIG. 46.18. Metzenbaum scissors (Richard Wolf Medical Instruments, Vernon Hills, IL). |
· Cyst aspiration needle (Fig. 46.19)
|
|
|
FIG. 46.19. Cyst aspiration needle. |
· Suction and irrigator
· Uterine manipulator (Fig. 46.20 and Fig. 46.21)
|
|
|
FIG. 46.20. RUMI uterine manipulator (Cooper Surgical, Shelton, CT). |
|
|
|
FIG. 46.21. Hulka uterine manipulator tenaculum (Richard Wolf Medical Instruments, Vernon Hills, IL) and Cohen Uterine Cannula (Karl Storz Endoscopy-America, Culver City, CA). |
An advanced laparoscopy set may also include:
· Needle holders (Fig. 46.22, Fig. 46.23 and Fig. 46.24)
|
|
|
FIG. 46.22. Five-millimeter needle holder (Olympus, Melville, NY). |
|
|
|
FIG. 46.23. Five-millimeter needle holder (Olympus, Melville, NY). |
|
|
|
FIG. 46.24. Five-millimeter needle holder (Karl Storz Endoscopy-America, Culver City, CA). |
· Knot pusher (Fig. 46.25)
|
|
|
FIG. 46.25. Knot pusher for extracorporeal suturing (Marlow Surgical, Roebling, NJ). |
· Vaginal delineator (Fig. 46.26)
|
|
|
FIG. 46.26. Koh Cup Vaginal Fornices Delineator (Cooper Surgical, Shelton, CT). |
· Babcock clamp (Fig. 46.27)
|
|
|
FIG. 46.27. Babcock atraumatic grasper. |
· lAlis clamp
· Adson forceps (Fig. 46.28)
|
|
|
FIG. 46.28. Adson forceps. |
· Corkscrew
· Single-tooth tenaculum
· Atraumatic bowel grasper
· Monopolar spatula (Fig. 46.29)
|
|
|
FIG. 46.29. Monopolar spatula for cutting and coagulation. |
· Endoscopic specimen retrieval bags (Fig. 46.30 and Fig. 46.31)
|
|
|
FIG. 46.30. Endo Catch instrument with a specimen bag (U.S. Surgical, Norwalk, CT). |
|
|
|
FIG. 46.31. Specimen retrieval bag (Cook Ob/Gyn, Spencer, IN). |
· Endoscopic suture ligatures (Fig. 46.32)
|
|
|
FIG. 46.32. Surgitie endoscopic suture ligature (U.S. Surgical, Norwalk, CT). |
· Microbipolar forceps
· Morcellator
· Rectal probe
Staplers
Endoscopic staplers that simultaneously ligate and divide tissue are available. In gynecologic procedures, they are used most commonly on the infundibulopelvic ligament, round ligament, fallopian tubes, and uteroovarian ligaments in laparoscopically assisted vaginal hysterectomies. They also may be used when excising endometriosis from the bowel (Fig. 46.33).
|
|
|
FIG. 46.33. Stapling device (U.S. Surgical, Norwalk, CT). |
Harmonic Scalpel
The active blade of the Harmonic Scalpel (Ethicon Endosurgery, Cincinnati, OH) vibrates at a rate of 55,000 cycles per second, resulting in coagulation and tissue separation. The scalpel is available as a 5- or 10-mm “hook,” “ball” dissector, spatula, or opposing jaws. Although electrical energy is not used, the tissue still becomes heated and a 2-mm lateral energy spread, which can cause thermal injury, may be seen.
Electrosurgery
Unipolar electrosurgical instruments are used to cut and coagulate tissue. Cutting occurs when there is sufficient voltage (at least 200 volts) between the electrode and the tissue to produce an electric arc. This arc concentrates the current to points along the tissue, resulting in a cutting effect. In contrast to cutting current, coagulation is produced through instrument contact with the tissue. Contact allows heating of the tissue followed by irreversible cellular damage, evaporation of intracellular water, and contraction of blood vessels and surrounding tissue. Electrosurgical burns may occur due to insulation failure, direct coupling (activated electrode makes unintended contact with another metal object in the area of the surgical field), or capacitive coupling (induction of stray current to a surrounding conductor through the intact insulation of an active electrode).
Bipolar electrosurgical instruments contain the electrical current between an active and return electrode, usually the two blades of forceps. The flow of alternating current is passed between the two electrodes rather than passing through the patient to a grounding pad. This eliminates the risk of capacitive coupling and stray current.
Laser
Lasers offer an alternative method of cutting and vaporizing tissue. The CO2 laser with a depth of penetration of 1 mm allows the surgeon some security when working around bowel, ureters, and large blood vessels. In addition, a CO2 laser will not traverse through water, thus irrigation fluid may be used as a backstop. The Coherent 5000L (Coherent Laser, Palo Alto, CA) laser offers high-power density over a short period of time, minimizing thermal damage to surrounding tissue. This laser uses a 13C isotope of CO2 with an 11.1-mm–wavelength beam. The wavelength of the CO2 purge gas in the operating channel of the laparoscope is 10.6 mm. Because the wavelengths are different, there is no absorption of the laser beam by the purge gas, keeping the power density 10 times more than at similar settings with other standard laser beams with 10.6-mm wavelengths. The 1.5-mm spot size is maintained at all power settings, offering precision, minimal surrounding tissue damage, and less charring.
Fiber lasers (potassium-titanyl-phosphate [KTP], argon, and Nd:YAG [YAG]) are introduced through small channels of the operating laparoscope or through ancillary trocars. The KTP and argon lasers may be used for cutting and coagulating. As the tip of the fiber approaches the tissue, the power density increases and the laser is used for cutting. As the tip is moved away from the tissue, the spot size increases and power density decreases rapidly. The clinical applications for the YAG laser are more limited. The YAG laser coagulates well, but it doesn't cut well unless a sapphire tip is used to increase the power density.
Handoscopy
Hand-assisted laparoscopy, or “handoscopy,” has become popular, mainly in the field of solid organ and bowel surgery. To date, the only gynecologic procedure where this device has been used is rectal resection for deep fibrotic endometriosis. The main advantage of handoscopy is that it allows the surgeon to regain the tactile feel of tissues lost in standard laparoscopies.
Physiologic Effects of the Pneumoperitoneum
The respiratory, hemodynamic, and renal consequences of the pneumoperitoneum are substantial but usually are well tolerated by the healthy patient. These changes may be severely problematic in the patient whose cardiopulmonary or renal system is compromised.
Respiratory Changes
Ventilation during laparoscopic surgery is altered by the increased intraabdominal pressure (IAP) of the pneumoperitoneum. The airway pressure required for adequate ventilation consequently is increased. Thoracic compliance, diaphragmatic excursion, and functional residual capacity are all decreased. Studies have shown that the increase in IAP alone reduces compliance by 30%; this may be decreased by another 20% when the patient is placed in a Trendelenburg position.
In addition to mechanical changes, the CO2 pneumoperitoneum produces changes in acid–base balance. Because carbon dioxide is absorbed rapidly from the peritoneal cavity, the minute volume must be increased as indicated by the end-tidal CO2 to prevent respiratory acidosis (Table 46.1).
|
|
|
TABLE 46.1. Ventilatory effects of carbon dioxide pneumoperitoneum |
Hemodynamic Changes
Circulatory changes seen during laparoscopic surgery are the result of the mechanical compressive effects of the increased IAP and its associated hormonal changes (Table 46.2). Catecholamines, angiotensin, and vasopressin are all increased, resulting in increased systemic vascular resistance. An increase in systemic vascular resistance results in an increase in mean arterial pressure and a decrease in cardiac index. The increased IAP also causes increased intrathoracic pressure, with resultant increases in central venous pressure, pulmonary capillary wedge pressure, and pulmonary vascular resistance.
|
|
|
TABLE 46.2. Hemodynamic effects of carbon dioxide pneumoperitoneum |
Renal Blood Flow Changes
Animal studies have shown an increase in renal vascular resistance and a decrease in renal perfusion and glomerular filtration rate secondary to increased IAP. A subsequent decrease in urine output may be observed and may continue to remain low 1 hour after release of the pneumoperitoneum (Table 46.3).
|
|
|
TABLE 46.3. Renal effects of carbon dioxide pneumoperitoneum |
Compromised Patient
The multiple cardiopulmonary and renal changes observed during CO2 laparoscopy are well tolerated by the healthy patient. Extreme caution must be taken when performing gaseous laparoscopy in patients with compromised respiratory function, ischemic heart disease, congestive heart failure, and renal dysfunction. These compromised states may even be considered relative contraindications to gaseous laparoscopy. The lowest IAP that allows adequate visualization should be used to minimize increases in intrathoracic pressure. An alternative consideration would be to use an abdominal wall lift method (elevating the ventral abdominal wall by an inflatable balloon or fan retractor), eliminating the consequences of CO2 in the peritoneum. The use of alternative gases such as argon, nitrous oxide, and helium for pneumoperitoneum has been considered. Carbon dioxide's advantages over these gases include higher solubility and, therefore, possibly fewer deleterious effects in event of gas embolism, ability to use cautery in its presence, and it is inexpensive. It is the surgeon's responsibility to take a careful history and perform appropriate preoperative diagnostic testing when determining a patient's candidacy for laparoscopic surgery. All of the advantages of laparoscopic surgery are inconsequential if the procedure is performed on an inappropriate patient.
Anatomy of the Anterior Abdominal Wall
Knowledge of the anterior abdominal wall vascular anatomy will reduce vascular complications associated with trocar placement. Of particular concern are the superior and inferior epigastric vessels. The superior epigastric artery, one of the terminal branches of the internal thoracic artery, enters first the rectus sheath and then the rectus muscle coursing near its lateral border. This artery and its adjacent vein often can be visualized by transillumination of the abdominal wall with the laparoscope.
Visualization of the ventral abdominal wall laparoscopically often will locate the deep inferior epigastric vessels. The artery, a branch of the external iliac, and its accompanying vein course along the abdominal wall peritoneum just lateral to the rectus muscle until midway between the symphysis pubis and umbilicus, where it blends into the body of the rectus muscle. These vessels may be seen medial to the insertion of the round ligament at the deep inguinal ring. Therefore, placement of the trocar lateral to the deep inguinal ring and lateral border of the rectus muscle will avoid injury to these vessels.
If placement of the trocar is too far laterally, branches of the superficial circumflex iliac vessels may be injured. Again, transillumination of the anterior abdominal wall using the laparoscope will assist in avoiding these vessels.
As a general guideline, the superficial and inferior epigastric vessels are located approximately 5.5 cm from the midline. The superficial circumflex iliac vessels are approximately 7 cm from the midline. Theoretically, a “safe area” would be 8 cm above the symphysis pubis and 8 cm from the midline. If transillumination is not effective due to a thick abdominal wall, the surgeon may consider insertion of a spinal needle through the abdominal wall at the selected trocar insertion site. If no bleeding is observed after removal of the needle, the location is likely safe for trocar placement.
Obtaining Intraabdominal Access
For most laparoscopic surgeons, obtaining access to the peritoneal cavity is the most anxiety-provoking step of the entire endoscopic procedure. There are a number of ways to obtain intraabdominal access for trocar placement and establishment of a pneumoperitoneum. None of the available methods precludes the possibility of complications from trocar or needle insertion. In general, these methods of entry can be classified as either open or closed.
An open entry uses the technique first described by Harry Hasson. An incision into the peritoneal cavity through all anterior abdominal wall layers at the umbilicus is made carefully. A blunt-tipped trocar is placed through the incision into the abdominal cavity. Insufflation is conducted through this trocar sleeve. This technique may reduce vascular injuries due to sharp trocar or needle placement, but the possibility of bowel injury still exits if there are abdominal wall adhesions.
The closed entry may be performed with or without the use of a Veress needle to insufflate CO2. Placement of the sharp trocar through the umbilicus without prior insufflation has lost favor due to the higher risk of bowel and vascular injuries.
Insufflation of CO2 through a Veress needle is the most common method of entry, although some would argue the open technique should become the method of choice. One technique of access using a Veress needle is performed in the following manner:
1. A vertical incision through the skin corresponding to the size of the trocar is made at the base of the umbilicus. Note that this incision ideally is made at the base of the umbilicus and not infraumbilically as is classically taught. This is because the distance between skin and peritoneum on the anterior abdominal wall is shortest at the base of the umbilicus. In addition, the peritoneum is firmly attached, which will prevent tracking through the subcutaneous tissue and subsequent retroperitoneal insufflation.
2. The Veress needle is inspected for sharpness and a functioning spring mechanism to extend the protective sheath in the absence of pressure.
3. The anterior abdominal wall inferior to the umbilicus is grasped with the nondominant hand and the umbilicus is moved in the caudad direction, further displacing it below the bifurcation of the aorta. Alternatively, the incision may be elevated by grasping the edges of the umbilical incision with two Alice clamps and lifting.
4. The tip of the Veress needle is held in the dominant hand between the thumb and forefinger while the ulnar palm rests on the patient's abdomen. The needle is inserted carefully at a 90-degree angle, through the base of the umbilicus, millimeter by millimeter, until a click is heard and resistance is no longer felt, identifying intraabdominal placement.
5. A saline-filled 10-cc syringe is attached to the Veress needle and aspirated, inspecting for blood or bowel contents. If only bubbles are visible, saline is injected and observed to fall from the trough on the needle into the peritoneal cavity.
6. The syringe is removed, the insufflation tubing (with CO2 turned on low flow) is attached, and the initial IAP is observed. If the pressure is greater than 10 mm Hg, the needle should be removed quickly to avoid retroperitoneal insufflation, which further displaces the peritoneum from its attachment to the anterior abdominal wall. A second needle placement attempt is then made.
7. Once intraperitoneal placement is confirmed, a CO2 pneumoperitoneum is obtained. Insufflation up to an IAP of 20 to 25 mm Hg, as initially described by Reich and others, remains one accepted method. This temporary increase in IAP increases the distance between abdominal viscera and the anterior abdominal wall (in the absence of adhesions) during primary sharp trocar placement through the umbilicus. It is also extremely beneficial for surgeons with small hands, who may find it difficult to grasp and further elevate the abdominal wall if the initial pressure is less than 20 mm Hg.
8. The end of the sharp trocar is held in the palm of the dominant hand, with the forefinger extended along the shaft as close to the sharp tip as possible. The tip is inserted through the umbilical incision until the fascia at the base of the umbilicus is felt. Insertion is carried through at a near-90-degree angle until the tip is felt to pass through the peritoneum. The trocar is then directed toward the pelvis to minimize risk of vascular or bowel injury.
9. After placement of the primary trocar, the intraabdominal placement is confirmed visually and the IAP is reduced to 12 to 15 mm Hg.
Alternative methods for obtaining pneumoperitoneum have been described and are useful in cases in which adhesions at or near the umbilicus are suspected. The most common method is insertion of the Veress needle in the left upper quadrant, followed by placement of a 5-mm trocar and laparoscope. Others have performed insufflation after inserting a Veress needle transfundally or through the posterior cul-de-sac into the intraabdominal cavity.
There are no prospective randomized studies comparing the safety and efficacy of open-entry with closed-entry techniques. The incidence of injuries is so low that a very large study population would be required to show any statistical difference. Randomized studies comparing the Veress needle with the direct trocar insertion technique favor the Veress needle. The vast majority of surgeons agree that the method used should be that with which the surgeon has the most experience and is, therefore, most comfortable.
Laparoscopic Procedures
Ectopic Pregnancy
Through earlier diagnosis, ultrasonography has reduced significantly the morbidity and mortality associated with ectopic pregnancies. In 98% of cases after the fifth week of pregnancy (when HCG levels are greater than 1,000), transvaginal ultrasonography can reliably visualize a normal gestational sac. The absence of an intrauterine sac above this level should alert the physician of a high likelihood of ectopic pregnancy. With the advent of methotrexate use, the total number of ectopic pregnancies treated surgically has decreased. Laparoscopy remains a standard for surgical management in the stable patient.
While obtaining informed consent, the surgeon must discuss management alternatives. Should the pregnancy alone be removed leaving the fallopian tube in place, or should a salpingectomy be performed? Assuming the pregnancy can be aborted without significant bleeding from the fallopian tube, this decision should be based on the status of the contralateral ovary and tube. If the contralateral tube and ovary are normal in appearance, without adhesions, then a salpingectomy or salpingostomy may be performed with a subsequent intrauterine pregnancy rate of 85% and a repeat ectopic rate of 90%. If the contralateral tube is impaired, then the subsequent intrauterine pregnancy rate is 46% and repeat ectopic rate 52%. In this situation, the affected fallopian tube should be removed.
Technique for Salpingostomy or Salpingectomy
Laparoscopic access is obtained as previously described. In addition to the umbilical port, two 5-mm lower abdominal ports are indicated, left and right. A suction-irrigator is used to aspirate the hemoperitoneum, if present. The pregnancy is identified within the fallopian tube, usually within the ampullary portion. The tube is stabilized with a Babcock or atraumatic grasper. There is considerable debate regarding the use of dilute vasopressin prior to making the incision on the antimesenteric side of the tube overlying the pregnancy. Clinicians must understand the use of vasopressin has the potential for delayed bleeding postoperatively. An incision parallel to the axis of the tube is now made on the antimesenteric side. This may be performed using a spoon, knife, or hook monopolar electrocautery, set at 50 to 80 watts to minimize bleeding. The suction-irrigator is used to “aquadissect” the attachments between the pregnancy and tube, thus aborting the pregnancy into the pelvis. Alternatively, the pregnancy may be grasped using atraumatic graspers and pulled from its attachment. It is then removed from the abdomen through the operating channel of a right-angle laparoscope or a 10-mm or larger port.
If significant bleeding is encountered or the pregnancy does not dissect freely, a salpingectomy may need to be performed. Again, the fallopian tube is grasped with an atraumatic grasper and lifted. The tube is transected approximately 1 cm from its cornual end. Transection is performed after complete desiccation using bipolar cautery via Kleppinger forceps or may be performed after suture ligation (a window is created within the mesosalpinx inferior to the ligation site). The mesosalpinx, immediately inferior to the fallopian tube, is then desiccated using bipolar cautery and transected, freeing the tube and pregnancy from its anatomic attachments.
Adnexal Mass
Laparoscopic management of adnexal masses is gaining acceptance but still conjures considerable debate. The patient's age, transvaginal sonographic findings, and CA-125 level (if indicated based on patient's age) will determine if a laparoscopic approach rather than laparotomy is acceptable. Ultrasonographic criteria for benign and malignant tumors are presented in Table 46.4 and Table 46.5. CA-125 levels are most useful in postmenopausal women. A level of 35 units in postmenopausal women carries a sensitivity of 81% and specificity of 91% for malignancy. If the level is greater than 50, then the sensitivity remains essentially the same and the specificity increases to 97%. In premenopausal women, sensitivity remains 60% as the level increases, but specificity increases from 73% at a level of 35 to 95% at a level of 100.
|
|
|
TABLE 46.4. Ultrasonographic criteria for malignant ovarian tumors |
|
|
|
TABLE 46.5. Ultrasonographic criteria for benign ovarian tumors |
A primary concern for those advocating laparotomy over laparoscopy for management of suspicious adnexal masses is the potential increased risk of rupture during laparoscopic surgery. Preoperative or intraoperative rupture changes a stage Ia ovarian carcinoma to a stage Ic. Studies have shown that intraoperative iatrogenic rupture of the tumor capsule does not adversely affect survival, but survival is negatively influenced by spontaneous or preoperative rupture. The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists guidelines for intraoperative management of adnexal masses are presented in Table 46.6. As a general rule, if malignancy is highly suspected, then a laparotomy and complete surgical staging procedure should be performed. If a laparoscopy is performed initially and malignancy subsequently is identified histologically, the staging procedure should be completed within 1 week.
|
|
|
TABLE 46.6. ACOG guidelines for laparoscopic intraoperative management of adnexal masses |
Technique for Ovarian Cystectomy
After obtaining intraperitoneal access and placement of trocars, the uteroovarian ligament is grasped to stabilize the ovary. The ovarian cortex overlying the cyst is incised very superficially so as not to rupture the cyst. This may be performed using a CO2 laser set at 5 to 10 watts, a monopolar electrode (knife, hook, spoon) set at 30 to 50 watts of cutting current, or scissors. The edge of the cut ovarian cortex is grasped with a biopsy forceps and elevated. The suction-irrigator is placed gently at the opening between cortex and cyst wall. Aquadissection is performed using Ringer's lactate. A blunt grasper is introduced within the space and the cyst is shelled out from its attachment to the cortex. The incision is made longer as necessary. The cyst is placed within an impermeable sac introduced through the umbilical port or through a culdotomy incision. For larger cysts, a zip-lock type sandwich bag may be gas sterilized and placed through the 10- to 12-mm umbilical port. The sac is then removed either through the umbilicus or transvaginally. A spinal needle may be used to aspirate the contents of the cyst within the sac prior to removal to decrease its volume.
Technique for Oophorectomy
The first step in an oophorectomy procedure is always identification of the adjacent ureter. The ureter is most easily located at the pelvic brim near the bifurcation of the common iliac. Its retroperitoneal course may then be followed and location relative to the infundibulopelvic ligament noted. Once certain of the ureteral location, the infundibulopelvic ligament is grasped gently, elevated, and brought medially using a Babcock or other atraumatic grasper. The ligament is then desiccated at its attachment to the ovary using bipolar cautery. It is then transected. Alternatively, an opening through the peritoneum inferior to the ligament may be created using scissors. Suture ligatures may then be placed and tied. After transection of the infundibulopelvic ligament, the uteroovarian ligament is desiccated and transected. Desiccation of the mesovarium is followed by transection, completely freeing the ovary. The ovary is then placed in an impermeable sac and removed as described previously.
Tubal Sterilization
Surgical occlusion of the fallopian tubes is the most common method of contraception in developing countries. The techniques have evolved from a laparotomy to minilaparotomy to a laparoscopic approach including excision, electrosurgical desiccation using bipolar cautery, and application of clips or rings.
A Pomeroy tubal ligation is easily performed laparoscopically by grasping the fallopian tube at its isthmic portion and placing a chromic endoloop suture around a segment of tube. The knuckle of tube may then be excised.
Two clips are approved by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration for tubal occlusion, the Hulka-Clemens clip and the Filshie clip. Both clips are placed properly at the proximal isthmus after the tube has been placed on stretch. The clip should be applied at 90 degrees to the long axis of the tube and advanced until the hinge reaches the tube, incorporating the mesosalpinx at its tip.
The falope ring is placed on the ampullary portion of the fallopian tube by grasping the tube with the applicator and drawing the tube inside the applicator. A 1- to 2-cm segment of tube is drawn into the ring.
Although sterilization failure rates are lowest with unipolar cautery, most are performed using bipolar cautery. Bipolar desiccation is performed correctly with an in-line ammeter (indicating complete desiccation), current set at 25 watts, and desiccation of three contiguous areas of the isthmus incorporating the blood supply from the mesosalpinx.
The results of the U.S. Collaborative Review of Sterilization study found that all methods of tubal occlusion are very effective, although failure rates were higher than expected. The Hulka-Clemens clip and bipolar methods carry the highest failure rates, likely due to improper application technique.
Myomectomy
Women with symptomatic leiomyomas who wish to retain their reproductive potential or who wish to retain their uteri are candidates for myomectomy. Most of these procedures are still performed abdominally, because laparoscopic myomectomy is one of the more difficult laparoscopic procedures. There is controversy as to whether a laparoscopic closure of the myometrium is comparable to a closure achieved in an open procedure. In general, a laparoscopic approach should not be selected if leiomyomas are larger than 5 to 8 cm, multiple, or embedded deep within the myometrium. If a laparoscopic approach is chosen, the patient should be informed of the potential increased risk of spontaneous uterine rupture prior to labor and of recurrence (33% after 27 months).
Most myomectomies can be performed with three trocar sites. One 10-mm trocar is placed umbilically and 5-mm ones in the lower left and right abdomen. A vertical incision is made in the myometrium overlying the myoma using a spoon electrode (or other electrosurgical instrument) set at 80 watts of cutting current to minimize bleeding. The incision is continued through the myometrium to the surface of the myoma, identifying the plane between the pseudocapsule and fibroid. The myoma is grasped with a 5-mm single-toothed tenaculum or corkscrew, and traction is applied. The plane between the fibroid and pseudocapsule is entered and adhesions released with a combination of blunt and sharp dissection. The suction-irrigator works well here for blunt dissection. The adhesive attachments are desiccated using bipolar forceps prior to their transection to minimize bleeding. These adhesions may also be vaporized using the CO2 laser. The process is continued until the base of the myoma is reached, where the remaining attachments are desiccated using bipolar cautery. The myoma is freed and placed in the posterior cul-de-sac for later retrieval. Hemostasis of the myometrium is achieved. A multilayer closure is now performed using single interrupted sutures placed and tied laparoscopically. Alternatively, if the operator is not skilled in laparoscopic suturing, or if there is a concern regarding obtaining a maximally tight closure, a small laparotomy incision may be made and the suturing performed abdominally. A uterine manipulator placed within the uterus can help to elevate the uterine incision to the laparotomy incision and make suturing through a smaller incision easier. The myoma is now removed from the abdomen. If a small laparotomy incision has been made, the myoma may be removed through this incision. Morcellation using a scalpel or scissors may be necessary if the myoma is larger than the incision. If the entire procedure has been performed laparoscopically, the myoma may be removed using a morcellator introduced through the umbilical incision and visualized with a 5-mm laparoscope placed in one of the lower trocar sleeves. Alternatively, a culdotomy incision can be made and the myoma removed vaginally. The culdotomy incision may then be closed vaginally or laparoscopically.
Hysterectomy
The advanced surgical skills required to perform a laparoscopic hysterectomy and the economic factors involved have limited the acceptance of this procedure in gynecologic practice. The laparoscopic hysterectomy or laparoscopically assisted vaginal hysterectomy was never intended to replace the vaginal hysterectomy. The primary role of this procedure is to reduce the number of abdominal hysterectomies performed. Seventy percent of hysterectomies in the United States are performed abdominally. A review of the data from the Health Insurance Commission Medicare in Australia showed a decrease in the incidence of abdominal hysterectomy from 70% in 1991-1992 to 57% in 1994-1995 after the introduction of laparoscopically assisted hysterectomies in private hospitals. The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists has agreed on the indications listed in Table 46.7 for laparoscopically assisted vaginal hysterectomy (there has been no comment on total laparoscopic hysterectomies, but the same indications inherently would apply).
|
|
|
TABLE 46.7. Indications for laparoscopically assisted vaginal hysterectomy |
Several randomized controlled trials comparing laparoscopically assisted vaginal hysterectomies with abdominal hysterectomies reported that the former are associated with significantly less postoperative pain, shorter hospital stays, faster return to work and normal activities, but possibly longer operative times.
Technique for Total Laparoscopic Hysterectomy
A uterine manipulator (e.g., RUMI system), a vaginal extender (e.g., Koh Cup Vaginal Fornices Delineator), and a pneumooccluder (Colpo-Pneumo Occluder; all products from Cooper Surgical, Shelton, CT) or similar instruments are put in place at the beginning of the procedure. A 10-mm reusable trocar is introduced through the umbilicus after pneumoperitoneum is obtained as described previously. Five-millimeter trocars are introduced into the lower left and right abdomen under direct visualization. The course of the ureters is identified retroperitoneally. If the ovaries are to be removed, the infundibulopelvic ligament is isolated, desiccated, and transected as described previously for oophorectomy. If ovaries are to remain, then the round ligament, fallopian tube, and uteroovarian ligaments are desiccated using bipolar forceps and transected approximately 1 cm from their uterine attachments. The anterior leaves of the broad ligament are incised bilaterally to meet in the midline, releasing the bladder peritoneal attachment to the lower uterine segment. The harmonic scalpel with the hook attachment works well to minimize oozing. The bladder is gently pushed inferiorly over the vaginal metal colpodelineator. The posterior broad ligaments are incised downward using scissors to the insertion of the uterosacral ligaments, allowing lateral retraction of the ureters. The uterine arteries are identified within the broad ligament, and the surrounding loose, areolar tissue is skeletonized in a blunt fashion. The uterine arteries are then desiccated completely, as indicated by the ammeter, by placing the bipolar forceps at right angles to the lower uterine segment on either side, above the level of the vaginal metal colpodelineator. The uterus should take on a bluish hue if complete desiccation has been achieved. The desiccated arteries are transected, freeing the cardinal ligament attachment.
The vaginal pneumooccluder balloon is then insufflated prior to the colpotomy incision. The vaginal metal colpodelineator is emphasized by pushing the uterus cranially. The harmonic scalpel with hook electrode is used to make a circumferential incision over the metal ring, releasing the cervicovaginal attachment. The occluder balloon is deflated, and the uterus is brought into the vagina and now serves as the pneumooccluder. Hemostasis of the vaginal cuff is achieved. The cuff is sutured and closed laparoscopically, incorporating the uterosacral ligaments for pelvic support. The uterus is then removed from the vagina.
Endometriosis
Surgical treatment of endometriosis usually is performed for pain or infertility. There are no randomized controlled trials comparing excision, vaporization, fulguration, and desiccation of endometriotic lesions. Although each method of destruction has its proponents, the authors prefer excision of deep fibrotic endometriosis and vaporization of superficial implants. The only definitive cure for endometriosis is surgical resection or complete destruction of the endometriotic lesion. Surgical management does not include bilateral salpingo-oophorectomy. Removal of the ovaries will not necessarily ensure relief of symptoms. Estrogen, in addition to that produced by the ovaries, also is produced by peripheral conversion of androgens in the presence of aromatase. Aberrant aromatase expression has been identified in some endometriotic implants, causing local production of estradiol within them. This may explain the reason for failures or “recurrences” after bilateral salpingo-oophorectomy or only superficial destruction of the implant.
Ovarian endometriomas should be treated by cystectomy rather than drainage and coagulation, as evidenced by the results of a randomized clinical trial. Often, these ovaries are adherent to the pelvic sidewall, adjacent bowel, or the opposing ovary. During adhesiolysis, the endometrioma often is ruptured, spilling its thick, chocolate-like fluid into the cul-de-sac. The thick fluid should be aspirated and opening to the endometrioma identified. If necessary, the opening is enlarged until the thick endometrioma cyst wall is identified. Using a biopsy forceps (single-toothed grasper), the cyst wall is grasped and peeled from its attachment to the ovarian cortex. Once hemostasis is achieved, the cortex usually does not require suture closure.
Complications
Information regarding entry access injuries is provided in a review reflecting the Physician Insurers Association of America (PIAA). They noted that entry access injuries occurred in between 5 per 10,000 and 3 per 1,000 patients undergoing laparoscopic surgery. Bowel, rectal, and retroperitoneal vascular injuries accounted for 76% of all injuries incurred in the process of establishing a primary port. The PIAA reported that approximately 50% of bowel injuries were unrecognized for 24 hours or longer following the laparoscopic surgical procedure. A delay in recognition, age over 59 years, and major vascular injuries were independent factors associated with death.
In a Canadian Task Force study, the overall complication rate for all laparoscopic procedures was 0.65%; for operative laparoscopy it was 0.80%. The American Association of Gynecologic Laparoscopists has noted similar results (1.45 complications per 1,000 procedures).
In a review of 32,205 gynecologic laparoscopic procedures in a Finnish study, 130 major complications were noted. The total complication rate was reported as 4 per 1,000 and, more specifically, 0.6 per 1,000 diagnostic laparoscopies, 0.5 per 1,000 sterilizations, and 12.6 per 1,000 operative laparoscopies. Intestinal injuries were reported in 0.7 per 1,000 procedures, incisional hernias in 0.3, urinary tract injuries in 2.5, major vascular injuries in 0.1. Overall, laparoscopically assisted vaginal hysterectomy was associated with the highest complication rate at 2.3%, with ureteral injuries occurring in 1% of women undergoing the procedure.
Gas and air emboli have been reported with both laparoscopic and hysteroscopic procedures. Oxygen saturation monitoring, as well as end-tidal carbon dioxide and, more recently, capnography and mass spectrometry, are designed to provide early diagnosis. If an embolus occurs, it frequently is accompanied by cardiac arrhythmia and cardiac arrest. It is beyond the scope of this chapter to provide detailed information regarding cardiopulmonary resuscitation.
Ureteral injury, as noted above, has been reported in association with minimally invasive surgery. Often times it is not recognized at the time of the initial procedure. The diagnosis should be considered when a patient exhibits postoperative fever, hematuria, flank pain, or evidence of peritonitis. Initial treatment with ureteral stenting on occasion is inadequate, resulting in subsequent ureteroneocystostomy. With respect to bladder injury, if one suspects such, distension of the bladder with methylene blue can identify a defect. If there is suspicion of ureteral injury, intravenous administration of indigo carmine frequently proves helpful in identifying the defect.
Other minimally invasive surgery–associated complications have included spleen laceration. The injury was reported in four patients, and predisposition included splenomegaly, with injury occurring primarily during trocar insertion. This was associated with a laparoscopic salpingoplasty. However, this complication is extremely rare.
Death, although extremely rare following minimally invasive surgical procedures, has been reported. It is more commonly associated with unrecognized trauma to the intestinal tract with ensuing sequelae. It also has been reported in association with major vascular trauma.
SUMMARY POINTS
· Endoscopic surgery has replaced open surgery for many commonly performed gynecologic procedures such as tubal sterilization, excision of unruptured tubal pregnancies, ablation of peritoneal endometriosis, and simple ovarian cystectomy.
· Endoscopically assisted vaginal hysterectomy with removal of the adnexal structures demonstrates the potential for this technology.
· Endoscopic procedures have several advantages. They can be performed on an ambulatory basis, require shorter recovery times, cause less postoperative pain, and improve the cosmetic impact of incisions.
· Endoscopic procedures require specialized equipment and a high degree of technical skill.
SUGGESTED READINGS
Introduction
Dicker RC, Scally MJ, Greenspan JR. Hysterectomy among women of reproductive age: trends in the United States. JAMA 1982;248:323–338.
Laparoscopy
Chandler J, Corson S, Way L. Three sprecta of laparoscopic entry access injuries. J Am Coll Surg 2001;192:478–491.
Isaacson K. Endometrial ablation: Is one technique best? Contemp Obstet Gynecol 2001:31–38.
Molloy D, Crosdale S. National trends in gynaecological endoscopic surgery. Aust N Z J Obstet Gynaecol 1996;36:27–31.
Morice P, Vaila J, Pautier P, et al. Port-site metastasis after laparoscopic surgery for gynecologic cancer. J Reprod Med 2000;45:873–874.
Sanfilippo JS, Levine R, eds. Operative gynecologic laparoscopy. New York: Springer Verlag, 1996.
Complications
Chang M, Shiau C, Chang C, et al. Spleen laceration, a rare complication of laparoscopy. J Am Assoc Gynecol Laparosc 2000;7:269–272.
Cooh B, Kwon D, Park K, et al. Late presentation of ureter injury after laparoscopic surgery. Obstet Gynecol 2000;95:370–379.
Harkki-Siren P, Sjoberg J, Kurki T. Major complications of laparoscopy: a follow-up Finnish study. Obstet Gynecol 1999;94:94–98.
Hershlag A, Loy R, Lavy G, et al. Femoral neuropathy after laparoscopy-a case report. J Reprod Med 1990;35:575.
Reich H, Ribeiro SC, Rasmussen C, et al. High-pressure trocar insertion technique. JSLS 1999;3:45–48.
Sadik S, Onoglu S, Mendilicogu I, et al. Urinary tract injury during advance gynecologic laparoscopy. Am Assoc Gynecol Laparosc 2000;74:569–572.
Speights S, Moore R, Miklos J. Frequency of lower urinary injury at laparoscopic Burch and paravaginal repair. J Am Assoc Gynecol Laparosc 2000;7:515–518.
Wang P, Lee W, Waun C, et al. Major complications of operative and diagnosis laparoscopy for gynecologic disease. J Am Assoc Gynecol Laparosc2001;8:68–73.