Differential Diagnosis in Primary Care, 4th Edition

Difficulty Swallowing (Dysphagia)

Swallowing is the function of the pharynx, larynx, and esophagus. This function may be impaired by two mechanisms: mechanical obstruction (e.g., carcinoma of the esophagus) and physiologic obstruction (e.g., pseudobulbar palsy).

Mechanical obstruction may result from intrinsic disease of the pharynx, larynx, and esophagus or extrinsic disease of the organs around the esophagus.

The mnemonic VINDICATE is useful in recalling the causes of mechanical obstruction as follows:

· V—Vascular indicates aortic aneurysms and cardiomegaly.

· I—Inflammatory should suggest pharyngitis, tonsillitis, esophagitis, and mediastinitis.

· N—Neoplasm should bring to mind esophageal and bronchogenic carcinoma, and dermoid cysts of the mediastinum.

· D—Degenerative and deficiency disease should suggest Plummer–Vinson syndrome of iron deficiency anemia.

· I—Intoxication immediately indicates lye strictures.

· C—Congenital and acquired anomalies should suggest esophageal atresia and diverticula.

· A—Autoimmune disease suggests scleroderma.

· T—Trauma would prompt the recall of ruptured esophagus, pulsion diverticulum, and foreign bodies that obstruct or injure the wall of the esophagus.

TABLE 23. Diarrhea–Physiologic Classification

Hyposecretion

Hypersecretion

Hypermobility

Hypomobility

Primary Malabsorption

Exudative

Gastric

Pernicious anemia
Iron deficiency
Gastric resection

Zollinger–Ellison syndrome

Dumping syndrome

Duodenal

Lactase deficiency
Sucrase deficiency

Blind loop syndrome

Secretion-induced

Biliary

Liver disease
Obstructive jaundice

Cholecystokinin induced

Cholecystokinin-induced
Regional ileitis

Pancreatic

Cystic fibrosis
Chronic pancreatitis

“Pancreatic cholera” (islet cell adenoma with vasoactive intestinal peptide)

Gastrin
Vasoactive intestinal peptide

Small Intestine

Cholera (e.g.,Escherichia coli)

Diabetic diarrhea
Drugs

Coffee
Serotonin-induced
Cathartic
Parasympatho-mimetic

Celiac sprue
Tropical sprue
Whipple disease
Intestinal lymphoma
Extensive resection

Regional ileitis
Salmonellosis

Large Intestine

Protein-losing enteropathy (e.g., villous adenoma)

Shigella
Ulcerative colitis
Amebiasis

Physiologic obstruction results from neuromuscular disorders at the end organ, myoneural junction, and lower and upper motor neurons.

1. End organ. This should suggest myotonic dystrophy, dermatomyositis, achalasia, and diffuse esophageal spasm.

2. Myoneural junction. This brings to mind myasthenia gravis.

3. Lower motor neuron. In this category one would recall poliomyelitis, diphtheritic polyneuritis, and brainstem tumors or infarctions.

4. Upper motor neuron. This structure prompts the recall of pseudobulbar palsy from cerebral thrombosis, embolism, or hemorrhage, multiple sclerosis, presenile dementia, and diffuse cerebral arteriosclerosis. It should also bring to mind Parkinson disease and other extrapyramidal disorders.

Approach to the Diagnosis

The age of onset is significant because carcinoma of the esophagus is rare before age 50, whereas achalasia and reflux esophagitis are more common in young and middle-aged adults. The onset is gradual in carcinoma and aortic aneurysms but more acute in reflux esophagitis and foreign bodies. Patients with achalasia have trouble swallowing both food and water, but those with carcinoma suffer the most, and often the only difficulty is swallowing food.

Association of other symptoms and signs is important. Neurologic findings will focus on the diagnosis of bulbar and pseudobulbar palsy whereas hematemesis and heartburn will suggest esophageal carcinoma or reflux esophagitis.

The barium swallow is still the most useful initial study to order. However, esophagoscopy and biopsy will lead to a definitive diagnosis in most cases of mechanical obstruction. If esophagoscopy is negative, one may resort to a mecholyl test to diagnose achalasia, a Tensilon test to exclude myasthenia gravis, and esophageal manometry to diagnose reflux esophagitis, scleroderma, and diffuse esophageal spasm.

Other Useful Tests

1. CBC (Plummer–Vinson syndrome)

2. ANA analysis (collagen disease)

3. Sonogram (laryngeal obstruction)

4. Videofluoroscopy (oropharyngeal obstruction)

5. Ambulatory pH monitoring (reflux esophagitis)

6. CT scan of the mediastinum (mediastinal mass, aortic aneurysm)

7. Gastroenterology consult

8. Therapeutic trial of proton pump inhibitor (reflux esophagitis)

9. Solid food scintigraphy (Achalasia)



If you find an error or have any questions, please email us at admin@doctorlib.org. Thank you!